College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Greatest: Michael Jordan or Kobe Bryant

Debate won't go away: who is best in basketball?

Published: Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Updated: Monday, May 18, 2009 16:05


To most sports fans, this topic has been a continuing debate for years. Love him or hate him, Kobe Bryant has emerged as possibly the biggest star in basketball in today's game.

Now that the basketball season is ended for Kobe, it's time to reevaluate the comparisons of Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant.

Jordan is a few years into his retirement and has taken more of the businessman role in the NBA. Bryant and his Lakers on the other hand just got eliminated in a first-round domination by the Phoenix Suns, thus creating conflict for the upcoming off-season in Los Angeles.

Taking a closer look at the comparison of Jordan and Bryant requires more than just subjective standpoints based on fan bias and common assumptions. Most longtime fans would agree that Michael Jordan is the superior player. However, some of the younger fans choose Kobe over MJ. When taking full analysis, it comes quite clear that MJ is the better basketball player, and possibly the best of all-time.

Jordan globalized basketball during his career with his unique athleticism and graceful style of play. When asked for the complete basketball player, he has the whole package. Jordan has a keen sense of putting the ball in the hoop by any means necessary as well as making the highly improbable look easy. It should be noted that Jordan played in the best defensive era in NBA history, which is largely due to the lack of sensitivity when calling fouls.

Bryant is the closest thing to Jordan we've seen in the history of basketball. He shares that same rare ability to score at will, no matter what a defense throws at him.

Although Bryant has not quite reached the same point in his career that Jordan has, it is still safe to compare the honors and awards each player has earned throughout their playing days. While these achievements are not necessarily everything, it is definitely a significant piece of information. Jordan has six NBA championships to Bryant's three. Jordan has been named MVP five times. Bryant has zero MVPs to his name. Bryant has three scoring titles, but Jordan eclipses that number with ten. Bryant has been acknowledged for his defense by being named to the all-defense team multiple times, but Jordan has been elected best defensive player of the year, something Bryant has never done. Jordan made a direct impact on the game when he arrived to the league and was the NBA's rookie of the year in 1984. Bryant developed his game after a couple of seasons before making any impact on the league. Yes, some of these awards can be based on a popularity contest as well as a reflection of a team, not an individual.

In respect to Bryant, in recent years, he has accomplished feats Jordan never did. There are two most notable by fans. The first is the 81-point performance Bryant made in a single game. Jordan's closest game to that only left him with 69 points. The other remarkable achievement occurred this year when Bryant scored at least 50 points in four straight games. Throughout Jordan's illustrious career, he never reached this number. Although, Jordan did score at least 50 points in three straight games on multiple occasions.

Bryant does have those two statistical marks over MJ but unfortunately for him, there are not too many more he excels at over Jordan. Jordan averaged more points, assists, rebounds, steals and blocks throughout his career than Bryant has in his career.

Jordan's playoff numbers exceed Kobe's as well. Nobody has outscored Jordan in the playoffs, considering his average for points per game is higher than every other player in NBA history. Also, Jordan holds the record for the highest points per game average in a single playoff series as well as for the NBA Finals.

Stats may not be everything in the playoffs, but while MJ posted these astounding numbers, he also led his team to six titles in a single decade, recording six NBA Finals MVPs while doing it. In Kobe's three titles, he has no NBA Finals MVPS due to him, not even being the best player on his team at the time.

Many Jordan backers argue that Bryant never could win without Shaq, while Bryant fans state that Jordan never won without Pippen. However, most people fail to remember the NBA title won in 1998 by Jordan and the Bulls. Why this championship was so special is because Scottie Pippen, Jordan's Robin, remained injured due to his back throughout the entirety of the playoffs. This caused MJ to put the team on his back and lead the Bulls to another title ultimately by himself, something Bryant has yet to do. Also, a key example of Bryant's failure to finish off in the NBA Finals was in 2004 when he had an ensemble of four future hall-of-famers in the starting lineup. In attempts to take over, Bryant took multiple unadvised shots as he got shut down by Tayshaun Prince and the Pistons. The Detroit Pistons dominated the series, winning four games to one.

Jordan won every single NBA Finals series he played in. Not once did he get shut down when it mattered the most.

If you look at Bryant and the Lakers' recent struggles, the first impression would be that Bryant has no support to help him win. However, if you take a closer look, Bryant is going through a similar phase Jordan did early on in his career. In both cases, both players scored spectacular amounts without getting their teammates involved. The difference between the two situations is that Jordan went through this phase in an immature stage of his career. Bryant is currently in his prime with less time to make a fix.

In fact, Jordan's latest stint in the NBA took place when he was 40 years old, plenty of time past his prime. During this time, it is arguable that Jordan had less support than Bryant did this past year. Each team finished with a final regular season record of 42-40. If Jordan can pull out the same amount of wins at the age of 40 as Bryant can during his prime, Bryant's ability to get his teammates involved should be seriously questioned.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

46 comments

Anonymous
Tue Mar 2 2010 19:04
well phil jackson said kobe had way harder shots, well see after kobe's retirement, currently Jordan has 6 rings and Kobe 4, but kobe is still playing however the stats say Jordan #1 and so do I
Anonymous
Mon Feb 22 2010 16:16
MJ wasnt compared to anyone, kobe is compared to MJ, MJ set the path on what it needs to be great, will kobe eventually out do MJ, probably....MJ pioneered greatnest in Basketball, but Kobe will be the GOAT...eventually, doesnt hurt to be second
Anonymous
Fri Feb 12 2010 10:53
kobe isn't finished. by the time he is done. MJ wont be able to touch him.
Anonymous
Wed Feb 10 2010 09:15
Jordan haters will hate this for sure, but Jordan is the greatest because he performs with an unstoppable will. When he wants to win, he will do whatever it takes, pay cuts, jawing with general management, getting in teammates' faces, staring down opponents, negotiating with refs, and just getting it done! He never choked in a final series, or any playoff series for that matter. Can't say that for Kobe. He choked in 2004 and in 2007. How many finals mvps has he? Not 6. that's for sure.
eddie webb
Sun Feb 7 2010 16:16
kobe Will go down as the greatest basketball player that ever lived
reno
Thu Jan 21 2010 01:42
Kobe will never be like Jordan,even Kobe knows that.
Jordan ova Kobe
Tue Jan 12 2010 05:27
MJ is the king.. Long live 23
Castro
Thu Jan 7 2010 01:41
Funny, I bet all those that say MJ are over 40 and those that say Kobe are 39 and younger. I thinks it's generational and it's no different for me. I think Oscar Robertson and Wilt Chamberlain are the best ever. Like all sports, the NBA too is now watered down. Having met MJ at a golf tournament in Tahoe and Kobe at a charity event here in LA, I can say Kobe is a better and more genuine human being. Mike leaves a lot to be desired as man. With all that said, Kobe is 8 years away from retirement so lets have this discussion in 2018. I think a lot of people's minds will be clearer then.
hmmm
Mon Jan 4 2010 09:33
man look kobe and MJ r bout the same but in 1 on 1 i think it will be a tie r sumthin r kobe will win by like 1 points cause jordan got older now n days wen its ova dey will dap it off.....now if on da same team o u already no!
Lil Laner
Fri Jan 1 2010 23:09
I agree with Jason. Seriously what if, lets say, you have the Cavs Vs. the Thunder, just saying, Thunder sucks and say LeBron is having a good night. he could easily score at least 60 points. so you actually Stats threwout the whole seasons career, as of know,
Jason
Fri Jan 1 2010 20:02
Thats an idiot way to think that because Kobe scored 81 that he could ever be better than MJ in that case you would also make the conclusion that Wilt is better than Kobe becaused he scored a 100 in a game so make valid points and look at the stats, Men Lie, Women Lie the Numbers Dont.
Your name
Thu Dec 10 2009 05:01
MJ will waste KB easy! wtf u talkin bout johnson young..
why are you asking for my name?
Thu Dec 3 2009 16:52
When I saw last night, The game between LA. vs Toronto were kobe scored 81 pts He took a lot of shots that were very difficult to shoot. and his drives, moves woah!!... amazing those footwork he was like dancing men! so smooth... and It puzzled through my mind if kobe was to play in jordan's era or the othwer way. I think kobe will out stand jordan.

and the game i watched its a replay of NBA greatest game. ahahah...

lakers 09-10 champs
Mon Nov 30 2009 15:01
i find the comparises of the article not really fair, but even so nobody can deny that mj was better than kobe. but im not so sure about that ''best player of all time'' i just don't know, cause you have a whole lot of other great players, russel, kareem, magic, hakeem, and dont even let me start talking about wilt the stilt and the big O!!

i think at the end of his career, kobe will have 3 finals mvp's and maybe about 6-8 championships.
lebron won't surpass kobe, kobe won't surpass jordan.

Your name
Thu Nov 26 2009 02:54
Kobe and Jordan are the father and son
LAKERFAN
Wed Nov 18 2009 00:37
Mr. young you must be a band geek because thats the worst thing i have ever heard and kobe bryant is my favorite player!!!!!!!!!
t dog
Tue Nov 17 2009 07:19
Bump all the stats... Bill Russell the man with 11 rings, but only 10 fingers said himself when asked to compare Lebron and Kobe that they were both naturally gifted and talented, but then he compared them to someone that won offensive player and defensive player of the year in the same year, and then he said, "now that was somethin'!" Johnson Young, guess who that was? You turkey! Happy Thanksgiving to all.
cg
Fri Oct 23 2009 00:29
johnson young is crazy, Show some respect for the greatest ever-Micheal Jordan.
brittany
Tue Oct 20 2009 21:30
Uhm Jordan is by far the greatest.. Kobe is just trying to catch up :D
crusader
Mon Oct 19 2009 10:26
hey johnson young, where are you when mj was soaring high and playing like there's no tomorrow? there's no ewings, barkleys, wilkins, masons, the bad boys from pistons, and so many jordan-bulls stopper that time and the likes of magic and bird... ..now, its only showtime.... they play not with their hearts but what their pockets can fill in...






log out