The Clarion

See Full HTML Site

Greatest: Michael Jordan or Kobe Bryant

Debate won't go away: who is best in basketball?

By Bo Brewer

Published: Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Updated: Monday, May 18, 2009

To most sports fans, this topic has been a continuing debate for years. Love him or hate him, Kobe Bryant has emerged as possibly the biggest star in basketball in today's game.

Now that the basketball season is ended for Kobe, it's time to reevaluate the comparisons of Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant.

Jordan is a few years into his retirement and has taken more of the businessman role in the NBA. Bryant and his Lakers on the other hand just got eliminated in a first-round domination by the Phoenix Suns, thus creating conflict for the upcoming off-season in Los Angeles.

Taking a closer look at the comparison of Jordan and Bryant requires more than just subjective standpoints based on fan bias and common assumptions. Most longtime fans would agree that Michael Jordan is the superior player. However, some of the younger fans choose Kobe over MJ. When taking full analysis, it comes quite clear that MJ is the better basketball player, and possibly the best of all-time.

Jordan globalized basketball during his career with his unique athleticism and graceful style of play. When asked for the complete basketball player, he has the whole package. Jordan has a keen sense of putting the ball in the hoop by any means necessary as well as making the highly improbable look easy. It should be noted that Jordan played in the best defensive era in NBA history, which is largely due to the lack of sensitivity when calling fouls.

Bryant is the closest thing to Jordan we've seen in the history of basketball. He shares that same rare ability to score at will, no matter what a defense throws at him.

Although Bryant has not quite reached the same point in his career that Jordan has, it is still safe to compare the honors and awards each player has earned throughout their playing days. While these achievements are not necessarily everything, it is definitely a significant piece of information. Jordan has six NBA championships to Bryant's three. Jordan has been named MVP five times. Bryant has zero MVPs to his name. Bryant has three scoring titles, but Jordan eclipses that number with ten. Bryant has been acknowledged for his defense by being named to the all-defense team multiple times, but Jordan has been elected best defensive player of the year, something Bryant has never done. Jordan made a direct impact on the game when he arrived to the league and was the NBA's rookie of the year in 1984. Bryant developed his game after a couple of seasons before making any impact on the league. Yes, some of these awards can be based on a popularity contest as well as a reflection of a team, not an individual.

In respect to Bryant, in recent years, he has accomplished feats Jordan never did. There are two most notable by fans. The first is the 81-point performance Bryant made in a single game. Jordan's closest game to that only left him with 69 points. The other remarkable achievement occurred this year when Bryant scored at least 50 points in four straight games. Throughout Jordan's illustrious career, he never reached this number. Although, Jordan did score at least 50 points in three straight games on multiple occasions.

Bryant does have those two statistical marks over MJ but unfortunately for him, there are not too many more he excels at over Jordan. Jordan averaged more points, assists, rebounds, steals and blocks throughout his career than Bryant has in his career.

Jordan's playoff numbers exceed Kobe's as well. Nobody has outscored Jordan in the playoffs, considering his average for points per game is higher than every other player in NBA history. Also, Jordan holds the record for the highest points per game average in a single playoff series as well as for the NBA Finals.

Stats may not be everything in the playoffs, but while MJ posted these astounding numbers, he also led his team to six titles in a single decade, recording six NBA Finals MVPs while doing it. In Kobe's three titles, he has no NBA Finals MVPS due to him, not even being the best player on his team at the time.

Many Jordan backers argue that Bryant never could win without Shaq, while Bryant fans state that Jordan never won without Pippen. However, most people fail to remember the NBA title won in 1998 by Jordan and the Bulls. Why this championship was so special is because Scottie Pippen, Jordan's Robin, remained injured due to his back throughout the entirety of the playoffs. This caused MJ to put the team on his back and lead the Bulls to another title ultimately by himself, something Bryant has yet to do. Also, a key example of Bryant's failure to finish off in the NBA Finals was in 2004 when he had an ensemble of four future hall-of-famers in the starting lineup. In attempts to take over, Bryant took multiple unadvised shots as he got shut down by Tayshaun Prince and the Pistons. The Detroit Pistons dominated the series, winning four games to one.

Jordan won every single NBA Finals series he played in. Not once did he get shut down when it mattered the most.

If you look at Bryant and the Lakers' recent struggles, the first impression would be that Bryant has no support to help him win. However, if you take a closer look, Bryant is going through a similar phase Jordan did early on in his career. In both cases, both players scored spectacular amounts without getting their teammates involved. The difference between the two situations is that Jordan went through this phase in an immature stage of his career. Bryant is currently in his prime with less time to make a fix.

In fact, Jordan's latest stint in the NBA took place when he was 40 years old, plenty of time past his prime. During this time, it is arguable that Jordan had less support than Bryant did this past year. Each team finished with a final regular season record of 42-40. If Jordan can pull out the same amount of wins at the age of 40 as Bryant can during his prime, Bryant's ability to get his teammates involved should be seriously questioned.

Although skills are arguably determined through subjective view, most would agree that Jordan exceeds Bryant in passing, rebounding, defense, winning, making his teammates better, attacking the basket and completing ultra-spectacular highlights. The skill in question for Jordan in comparison to Bryant would have to be his shooting. However, Jordan's career field goal percentage of 49.8 percent is drastically better than Bryant's. Not once has Bryant averaged at least 50 percent in even one single season.Bryant's 3-point shooting and free throw shooting is better by a hair, but this only includes regular season play. Jordan's shooting percentages are overall better than Bryant's when it comes to the playoffs.

Another category that some find debate in would be shooting in the clutch. Jordan is famously known for his spectacular game winners, and Bryant is getting the same great reputation. However, in a study made beginning with the last year of Jordan's career, Jordan outplayed Bryant in the clutch by shooting almost seven percentage points better in such situations. This is while an older, chubby Jordan is supposed to be in the worst shape of his career, having knees that can barely function, and in one of his worst shooting seasons of his career. Bryant makes plenty of game winners in the regular season, but nobody has made more huge shots in the playoffs than Jordan. Jordan's ability to take over in the fourth quarter is undeniably the best ever, especially in the postseason where it matters the most.

With all the statistics, awards, and championships, Jordan seems like the easy pick over Bryant as the superior basketball player. His skill set, selfless attitude, and basketball smarts outclass Bryant's. Jordan is considered by many the greatest basketball player ever. If Bryant wants to be seen in the same light as "His Airness," he has a long, rough road ahead of him.

Comments

47 comments
Anonymous
Tue Apr 26 2011 21:49
jordan was aw3some
Anonymous
Mon May 10 2010 11:30
imagen mj vs kb
Anonymous
Mon May 10 2010 11:28
i think that kobe & michael jordan r the best !!!!!!!!!! and ther is now one beter than them both!!!!!!!!
just a thought
Thu May 6 2010 20:47
Its intriguing that a discussion over two great athletes provocates more talk than any other article in this press. It makes one wonder if its the greatness that we aspire to, or the fact that one can sit on the other side of a screen, voice ones opion, be "heard" and in some sublte way conqure a greatness of their own. What is it that we are all chasing anyway?
Anonymous
Wed May 5 2010 11:16
michael is way better than kb, all the talk about the 90s bein the worst years of basketball may be true but michael played with love and heart while kobe just plays to be "cool" kobe may be a good basketball player but he isn't great. kobe has a team to support him michael carried his team. Yes, they weren't all terrible basketball players but without the heart and confidence of michael alot of the players wouldn't have played to their abilities. This comparison is ridonkilous, Michael Jordan is better than Kobe Bryant anyday. Oh and Kobe may have dropped 55 on Michael but how far was that in Michaels career almost closing time for Michael, everyone loses talent as they get older, here soon about 6 years someone is gonna drop 55 on Kobe probably more because Kobe will choke just like always.
Anonymous
Tue May 4 2010 12:09
kobe is kobe, jordan is jordan, no comparison whatsoever!
Anonymous
Thu Apr 29 2010 21:30
"kb is a copy cat no originality,get ur own style kb.lebron and dwane are better than u,bcause they are real,they dont copy no one not like kb." --- Whoever said this is an idiot. MJ is the best that has played with the rings to prove it. Kobe's "style" may mimic the greats, but it works. The game of basketball is not a fashion show.
cmon people are you serious?
Tue Apr 27 2010 01:35
Michael Jordan is and will always be the greatest basketball player that ever lived.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 21 2010 15:38
First of all your english makes me want to see how many times I can jump off of my house before you graduate third grade. Second off I agree that Michael is the best there's ever been, but Phil Jackson continues to have success without Michael Jordan on his team. The man knows how to coach the game, and his players execute for him. Coaching is a huge part of what makes good players great.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:36
phil jackson,why he bacame famous coach,b coz of mj.ur no body without mj b4,mj makes u look good n papular, u r traitor n greedy for money,ur not a good coach,mj is the best.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:32
in my country we dont even pay attention to kb games,why?coz he make us sick,copying mj.get out of town. KB be urself dont copy our hero.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:28
i feel so sorry for those guys who they think kb is better than mj,u must be really stupid for believing that,
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:25
kb is a copy cat no originality,get ur own style kb.lebron and dwane are better than u,bcause they are real,they dont copy no one not like kb.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:22
kb who,mj is the best he so famous in the whole world.kb just notice bacause of his move that he imitate from our guy mj.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 20 2010 15:19
mj he is r man,he is the best player ever.kb who.we dont even know him in out contenent.kb is just a copy cat no originality.
Anonymous
Sat Apr 10 2010 14:45
Kobe schooled Jordan when kobe dropped 55 points on michael jordan
Anonymous
Fri Apr 2 2010 20:49
Want to appear as a fool to older, long-time, objective basketball fans?
Compare another player to MJ.
Want to look flat-out stupid and ignorant?
Compare Kobe to MJ.
It is quite literally PREPOSTEROUS.
But it will continue, because it's a simple way for NBA writers to get somebody to read their article.
john jones
Wed Mar 17 2010 12:19
If Kobe is better than Michael, how is it that he played on much better teams throughout his career, but is still a couple titles short of his Airness? Kobe has always played on really good teams. Michael was stuck playing with a group of average guys for the first 3-4 years of his career.
I don't know anyone who can honestly say Kobe is greater. Maybe if the NBA tightened up on defense, allowed hand checking, ignored a lot of ticky tack fouls and let people play, and if a team who was good on defense formulated the Kobe rules, designed to stop Kobe, or at least slow him down, and Kobe could still perform at this current level, I would say he would be almost as good as Jordan. To be better, he would have to outperform him under these circumstances, because that's what Jordan dealt with for most of his career.
john jones
Wed Mar 17 2010 12:11
Michael is better at getting easy shots. That's what Phil really said. He didn't mean Kobe is better at hitting tough shots. How can that be when you can't even legally hand check anymore? Michael is a better clutch player in the most important games. He leads Kobe overall in shooting in the playoffs. He leads him in assists, steals, blocked shots, scoring titles, championships, mvps, and finals mvps. And Kobe jumped straight out of high school, which gives him 3 more years over Jordan, to pile up stats!!!
Canine32
Mon Mar 15 2010 17:43
nobody's like mike!

Most Commented

Most Popular